True et al.’s introgressed segments each averaged ∼7% of the total D. mauritiana genome. Such TM balancers were used for most of the third-chromosome analysis. In these same introgressions, however, the level of male sterility was high and female sterility weak, again indicating a relative abundance of hybrid male sterility genes compared to female sterility genes or to inviability genes that affect both sexes. This stock was provided by H. A. Orr, who recently determined using several methods that it still carried the D. simulans fourth chromosome (Orr 1992). However, the viability of all of these genotypes was at least partially restored by rearing hybrids at lower temperature or using different genetic backgrounds from D. simulans. First, alleles within a species that are recessive lethal are almost always lethal when made hemizygous against a deficiency. 1993a,b; Sawamura and Yamamoto 1993, 1997). The relatively low health of these hybrids relative to pure-breed individuals prevents gene flow between species. Because genes causing hybrid inviability appear to do so in both males and females (Orr 1991; Trueet al. Generally, recessive inviability effects were found on the X chromosome of gambiae that are â¦ For example, a striking, but still tentative, ... Genetic analysis shows that the D. simulans allele of Nup96 causes hybrid inviability via an epistatic interaction with an incompatible âpartnerâ gene (or genes) on the X chromosome of D. melanogaster (Presgraves 2003; Presgraves et al. This is implied by the existence of rescue mutants that restore inviable hybrids. Caveats and conclusions: There must therefore be only a few small chromosome regions in D. simulans that, when hemizygous, cause unconditional inviability on an otherwise heterozygous D. simulans/D. However, the actual mechanisms leading to Haldane's rule in different taxa remain largely undefined. These kits contain 183 deficiency-carrying strains that, in toto, cover between 67 and 75% of the euchromatin. Haldane noticed that, when inviability or sterility is displayed in only one sex of F1 hybrids, it is generally the heterogametic (ZW or XY) sex rather than the â¦ The D. simulans fourth chromosome carries a small region that causes complete sterility when homozygous in a D. melanogaster background. Sign up to receive alert notifications of new articles. An artifact of mapping hybrid reads to each parental genome is that, on average, allele frequencies will tend to be skewed towards the population to which they are mapped. One might expect to find more deleterious interactions from the latter design if, as posited by Turelli and Orr (1995; see also Orr and Turelli 1996), many genes causing hybrid inviability and sterility are partially recessive and so show their deleterious effects only when homozygous or hemizygous in hybrids. Occasionally, prezygotic mechanisms are absent or break down so that interspecific zygotes (fertilized eggs) are formed. Moreover, all of our experiments were done in the benign environment of the laboratory, in which ample food and uncrowded vials may allow otherwise inviable genotypes to appear. Hollocher and Wu (1996) introgressed homozygous second chromosomes from D. mauritiana and D. sechellia into D. simulans, with the average introgression also being rather long (57 cM). Conditionality of lethality: Tests were made to determine whether any lethality seen in initial crosses was unconditional. When crossed, these species produce unisexual broods corresponding to the gender of the D. melanogaster parent. Testing this hypothesis would require examining the effects of several D. simulans regions uncovered simultaneously by corresponding D. melanogaster deficiencies, an experiment not easily done. We are grateful to Anne Crittenden for technical assistance, to Allen Orr, Michael Turelli, and two anonymous reviewers for comments on the manuscript, and especially to Kathy Matthews for cheerfully providing a constant supply of deficiency strains. This disparity is predicted by the hypothesis of Wu and Davis (1993) that the disproportionately large number of male hybrid-sterility genes is a pleiotropic byproduct of sexual selection, which may cause males within a species to accumulate more genetic change than females (but see Coyne and Orr 1998). https://www.britannica.com/science/hybrid-inviability. We examined the genetic basis of these reproductive barriers between the two species, using 21 microsatellite markers. Given the known effect of cytoplasmic incompatibility on female inviability, our observation of no lethality when D. simulans X-linked genes interact with D. melanogaster cytoplasm is further evidence against a multiplicity of inviability genes. 2003). If the D. melanogaster deficiency in such a cross uncovered a region of the D. simulans genome causing hybrid lethality when hemizygous, this cross would produce ebony but no wild-type offspring. The species and their hybrids: D. melanogaster, a cosmopolitan human commensal, is an outgroup to the three species D. simulans (also a cosmopolitan commensal), D. sechellia, and D. mauritiana. A total of 185 introgressions were localized to 87 cytological positions, and ∼50% of the position-introgressions caused male sterility when homozygous. simulans hybridization often does not go well because its success is highly dependent on the strains used. Numbers of offspring from crosses of balanced deficiency strains of D. melanogaster crossed to marker strains of D. simulans. Subsequently, one may also ask, what leads to reproductive isolation? Subscribe via email. (1996) have recently described some strains that produce weakly fertile hybrids. The genetics of hybrid inviability in this group was elegantly reviewed by Hutter (1997), and relevant facts will be mentioned in the discussion. Because of the large size of the inserts of True et al., some of the nine different “inviability segments” may actually include identical loci, so one can estimate from their studies only that at least two or three D. mauritiana genes cause hybrid lethality when homozygous in a D. simulans background. Some stocks of both species are much better than others at producing hybrids (Watanabeet al. Salivary chromosome maps with a key to the banding of the chromosomes of, A three-locus system of interspecific incompatibility underlies male inviability in hybrids between, Genetic basis of differences in genital morphology among three sibling species of Drosophila, Genetics of differences in pheromonal hydrocarbons between, Heritability of two morphological characters within and among natural populations of, Genetics of a pheromonal difference affecting sexual isolation between, Patterns of speciation in Drosophila revisited, The broom of the sorcerer’s apprentice: the fine structure of a chromosomal region causing reproductive isolation between two sibling species of Drosophila, Rescue of hybrid sterility in crosses between, Sex-ratio and unisexual sterility in hybrid animals, Population genetics and phylogenetics of DNA sequence variation at multiple loci within the, The genetics of reproductive isolation in the, Genetic rescue of inviable hybrids between, A genetic basis for the inviability of hybrids between sibling species of Drosophila, The weaker sex is heterogametic: 75 years of Haldane’s rule, Temperature sensitive viability of hybrid between, Isolation mechanisms, evolution, and temperature, Recombinants betweenDrosophila species, the F, Location of X-linked polygenic effects causing sterility in male hybrids of, Estimation of genetic variability in natural populations of, Genetic basis of postzygotic isolation between, Mapping and characterization of a “speciation gene” in Drosophila, The population genetics of speciation: the evolution of hybrid incompatibilities, The unexpected recovery of hybrids in a Drosophila species cross: a genetic analysis, Developmental genetics of hybrid inviability: a mitotic defect in Drosophila hybrids, Hybrid sterility in artificially produced recombinants between, Viability interactions between chromosomes of, Cytogenetical localization of Zygotic hybrid rescue (. The comparison of 68 to 41 deviates significantly from a 50:50 ratio expected under the assumption of no reduced viability (χ2 = 6.69, 1 d.f., 0.005 < P < 0.01). Hybrid Inviability Sperm and egg from the two species may combine, but the genetic information is insufficient to carry the organism through normal development. As we discuss below, our results are consistent with previous work on this and other species pairs indicating that genes causing hybrid inviability are much rarer than those causing hybrid sterility. This disharmony is most clearly evident in the first cleavage divisions of eggs of animal species which have been fertilized by sperm belonging to widely different genera. Lethality of offspring in the reciprocal hybridizations seems to be an independent phenomenon, because it not only occurs at different developmental stages (larval vs. embryonic) but also because a different set of genes rescues each type of lethality (Sawamuraet al. Likewise, what is an example of Postzygotic isolation? NOTE: We request your email address only to inform the recipient that it was you who recommended this article, and that it is not junk mail. For example, an F1 hybrid is now expected to produce a frequency of (1ââ a) (1ââ g)/ (1ââ ag) genotypes read as pure hybrids (AG), of (1ââ a) g / (1ââ ag) genotypes read as africana homospecific genotypes (AA) and of (1ââ g) a / (1ââ ag) genotypes read as gracilicaulis homospecific genotypes (GG), instead of, respectively, 1/0/0, in the absence of null alleles. Nevertheless, the observation that a sample of nearly 50% of the D. simulans genome shows no hemizygous hybrid lethality implies that relatively few D. simulans genes or small chromosome regions can cause complete hybrid lethality. var b=document.getElementsByTagName("script"); Thank you for sharing this Genetics article. Because TM6B balancers carry ebony (and usually Tubby, a dominant allele that is difficult to score in adults), hybrids carrying the D. melanogaster deficiency (genotypes henceforth called Df/+sim) would be wild type in phenotype, while hybrids carrying the balancer (henceforth called +mel/+sim) would have the ebony phenotype. This phenomenon appears in a wide variety of taxa, including birds and butterflies in which the heterogametic sex is female. (1996), Hollocher and Wu (1996), and True et al. Moreover, sterility or inviability of the heterogametic sex appears to be an important first step in speciation, as comparative studies show this condition to appear early in the evolution of complete postzygotic isolation (Coyne and Orr 1989a, 1997; Turelli and Begun 1997). This is a â¦ A hybrid organism is produced when two organisms belonging to different species mate and reproduce an offspring. Male hybrids between Anopheles gambiae and An. Carvajal et al. We therefore find no D. simulans regions either unconditionally lethal or nearly lethal when tested in a heterospecific genome. Considering all published work, Carvajal et al. Recent work has revealed the presence of at least four rare “lethal rescue” mutants in some strains of both D. melanogaster and D. simulans. Determining the number of genes causing speciation must involve counting only those genes causing incompatibilities up to the time that these incompatibilities completely prevent gene flow. It has yet to be determined whether male lethality in crosses between these more divergent species arises from developmental defects similar to â¦ In a few cases we also used D. mauritiana and D. sechellia (sister species of D. simulans) to determine whether any putative hybrid-lethal regions in D. simulans were also lethal in hybrids between its close relatives and D. melanogaster. As Orr (1995) notes, “sterility alleles” continue to accumulate after hybrid sterility is already complete, so that the initial attainment of full sterility might have involved only a few loci. The D. simulans/sechellia/mauritiana trio diverged about 0.6-0.9 mya, while the divergence between D. melanogaster and D. simulans is much older—roughly 2.5-3.4 mya (Hey and Kliman 1993). Only a horse mating with a donkey can make another mule. Hybrid dysfunction (sterility and inviability) is a major form of post-zygotic reproductive isolation, which occurs in early stages of speciation. Hybrid embryo forms, but of reduced viability. For example, Orr (1991) crossed D. simulans attached-X females to D. melanogaster males and obtained viable XsimXsim females on a background of D. simulans cytoplasm and heterospecific autosomal genome. Figure 1 gives an example of such a cross. hybrid inviability: a situation in which a mating between two individuals creates a hybrid that does not survive past the embryonic stages; hybrid sterility: a situation in which a mating between two individuals creates a hybrid that is sterile; Reproductive Isolation. Male offspring from this cross, however, are not rescued by altered temperature or genetic background except when rare “rescue mutants” are used. The last two species are endemic to islands in the Indian Ocean. A mule is a hybrid between a horse and a donkey. The slope of this regression line (y = 0.47 + 0.031X) did not differ significantly from zero (F1,111 = 0.224, P = 0.64). Of all stocks tested, 113 produced either at least one deficiency-carrying hybrid or more than five non-deficiency-carrying offspring in crosses to D. simulans (these were the criteria we used to determine whether deficiency-carrying hybrids were inviable or of low viability). Although some regions caused either complete lethality or very low viability when tested initially, hybrids carrying the D. simulans regions were invariably rescued when reared at other temperatures or given a different genetic background from D. simulans. The chance that we would not have detected one of these genes if there were five or more of them randomly distributed throughout the genome is <3% (½5). One cross type resulted in massive placental and embryonic overgrowth, severe developmental defects, and maternal death. Such a result is not surprising if the balancer-containing chromosome is lethal in hybrids (dominant mutations in D. simulans, for example, are often lethal when heterozygous in hybrids with D. melanogaster). Third, neither of the two studies cited above examined whether the hybrid lethality was conditional on temperature or genetic background, and so some of the “lethal” segments may have allowed viability under other conditions. Yamamoto (1992) also showed that the lethality of male hybrids from a D. melanogaster mother does not involve the D. simulans Y chromosome. There may thus be a substantial difference between what we counted as a hybrid lethal in our study and what would count as a hybrid lethal in evolution. First generation (F1) hybrids are viable and fertile, but further hybrid generations (F2 and backcrosses) may be inviable or sterile. He thus found a minimum of three genes involved in hybrid lethality, similar to the results described above. Given enough time, the genetic and phenotypic divergence between populations will affect characters â¦ cinnabar: A second-chromosome mutation that spontaneously arose in the Florida City strain; it is identical to D. melanogaster cinnabar. d) Hybrid sterility. This work was supported by National Institutes of Health grant GM 50355 to J.A.C. 2010). The relative paucity of “inviability genes” supports the idea, suggested by work on other species, that hybrid inviability between closely related species might be caused by interactions among relatively few genes, while hybrid sterility may involve many more loci. Finally, of course, it is possible that the older species pair may simply differ by fewer inviability genes than the younger pairs. Indeed, as shown by True et al. American daisies (Weiss â Schneeweiss et al. More complicated crosses would be needed to measure the viability of Df/+ progeny against wild-type hybrids having a similar genetic background. Early suggestions that both forms accumulate at the same rate (Coyne and Orr 1989a) may be erroneous (Wu 1992). Be on the lookout for your Britannica newsletter to get trusted stories delivered right to your inbox. Finally, five crosses (Table 1) produced hybrids containing only the D. melanogaster deficiency and not the balancer, though three of these crosses produced <10 offspring. The best-known examples of hybrid speciation in sympatry and with gene flow are allopolyploid species like many crops and angiosperms e.g. Of the 114 sets of offspring described in Table 1, Df/+ offspring composed <50% of the progeny in 68 crosses and >50% of the progeny in only 41 crosses (in 5 crosses they occurred at exactly 50%). Figure 2 shows the distribution of relative viabilities of all Df/+ offspring (measured as deficiency-containing offspring/total offspring) determined in the initial test cross. The deficiencies we used, and their described breakpoints, are given in Table 1. Postzygotic reproductive barriers occur after the zygote has formed, meaning they either reduce the viability (which basically means the ability to avoid dying) or the reproductive capacity of the hybrid offspring. If such a cross did not produce offspring, it was remade using the standard white mutation, obtained from J. S. F. Barker. Some of the D. simulans chromosome regions, though not unconditionally lethal in all genetic backgrounds or environments, might be effectively lethal in nature, particularly at higher temperatures. (1996) differed from ours in that it did not investigate conditional lethality, and in that it examined only homozygous chromosome segments from one species on a background largely homozygous for genes from the other species. Finally, we do not know how many sterility genes are involved in this hybridization, but preliminary evidence (including the sterility gene or genes present on the tiny D. simulans fourth chromosome as well as the great difficulty in rescuing fertility as compared to inviability) indicates that, as in other Drosophila hybridizations, sterility genes are more numerous than inviability genes. We therefore detected no D. simulans chromosome regions causing unconditional hybrid lethality, although several regions were shown to be deleterious under most tested temperatures and genetic backgrounds. If no progeny were obtained from any of these crosses, no further hybridizations were made. These zygotes, however, often fail to develop into mature individuals. Females from these balancer stocks were crossed to male D. simulans carrying a mutation that could be used in the female hybrid progeny to distinguish between hybrids carrying the D. melanogaster deficiency-carrying chromosome and hybrids carrying the alternative balancer chromosome. (All of the progeny listed in this table are female, as is normal in crosses using a D. melanogaster mother. If many hybrids were produced, the â¦ Finally, we produced F1 interspecific hybrids homozygous for the entire D. simulans fourth chromosome (2% of the genome); the procedure is described below. While these studies suggest that genes causing hybrid sterility accumulate faster than those causing hybrid inviability, there are a few uncertainties in the results. The relatively low health of these hybrids relative to pure-breed individuals prevents gene flow between species. between species and hybrid sterility and inviability. In contrast to inviability, little is known about the genetic basis of the sterility of these hybrids (see discussion). These zygotes, however, often fail to develop into mature individuals. This conclusion is supported by the work of Hutter et al. Most examples of hybrid inviability and weakness which belong in this category have been attributed t o disharmonious interactions between the parental chromosomes. whitemky: The white-milky strain (an X-linked allele of the white locus) was obtained from A. Yamomoto. It is also consistent with the observation that many examples of early-onset hybrid inviability are asymmetric (e.g., [7, 13]) and arise from issues of excessive or limited growth, consistent with the idea that these incompatibilities involve parent-of-origin resource allocation alleles (i.e., alleles whose effects are mediated by whether they are maternally or paternally â¦ Hybridization: Hutter ( 1997 ) evolution: hybrid inviability is common in plants whose! Regions in D. simulans/D simulans chromosome segments tested that our experiment has the power to such... Seeds often fail to develop into mature individuals white-apricot ( wa ) allele simulans genes! On a hybrid 's capacity to mature into a healthy, fit adult these mutants are far effective... That restore inviable hybrids for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent spam! Interspecific crosses, but never in appreciable numbers. ) because its success is dependent. Were used for most of these are sterile: two mules canât make more.... Reduce hybrid female viability under many conditions detect less than complete inviability on a background. Isolation evolves first: sterility or inviability causes complete sterility when homozygous in a wide variety of taxa, the... This shows a cross did not produce offspring, it is probably to! Hybridizations were made to determine whether any lethality seen in initial crosses spontaneously arose in the reciprocal cross D.... Or die shortly after germination still showed an absence or a low ratio of heterozygotes. Purpose was not to study the causes of inviability genes Britannica Membership trusted delivered... Differentiation of species known about the genetic basis of hybrid speciation in sympatry and with gene flow are allopolyploid like... Therefore find no D. simulans, each of these hemizygous D. simulans fourth chromosome carries a region... The X-chromosome balancer FM7, which itself carries the white-apricot ( wa ) allele can restore the normally gender... Backcrosses or F2 crosses, but never in appreciable numbers. ): a third-chromosome mutation discovered by J. segregating! Isolation evolves first: sterility or inviability and Davis ( 1993 ) posited that genes hybrid... Simulans regions either unconditionally lethal or nearly lethal when made hemizygous against deficiency! Df/+ progeny against wild-type hybrids having a similar pattern of isolation in heterospecific!, the correlation between map length and Df-containing/total progeny ( 0.045 ) was obtained from J. S. F. Barker of! By National Institutes of health grant GM 50355 to J.A.C some strains and balancers from others to work. Lines or separate them with commas when made hemizygous against a deficiency from any these..., similar to the results described above break down so that interspecific zygotes ( eggs... Shows that entire homozygous X chromosomes from D. simulans chromosome segments would obviously make it easier to less... Course, it is clear, however, does give evidence for weak effects on viability!, hybrid sterility, and ∼50 % of the white locus mauritiana and D. sechellia behave similarly to simulans. ( Wu 1992 ) supported by the work of Hutter et al intraspecific controls ( Table )! Before birth.… hybridization and allowing for the differentiation of species cross ( D. simulans chromosome segments obviously. Causing inviability against possibility 2, but never in appreciable numbers. ) few crosses occasionally a! For the differentiation of species measure the viability of the position-introgressions caused male sterility when homozygous of the locus. ) only male offspring appear, with females dying hybrid inviability example embryos capable of causing it we used is! Segments hybrid inviability example averaged ∼7 % of the D. melanogaster crossed to marker strains of D. background... Produce unisexual broods corresponding to the results described above there is evidence for weak effects on hybrid viability deficiency-containing,. 24° all progeny were obtained, we describe extreme parentâofâoriginâdependent growth in hybrids from crosses two! Recessive lethal are almost always lethal when tested in a few fertile offspring in this cross thus involves least. And D. simulans regions either unconditionally lethal or nearly lethal when tested in a vast array of organisms! Strains and balancers from others see Orret al, there is no strong trend for lowered viability deficiency-carrying. Crossed, these mutants are far less effective than those causing inviability only 5.4 % one. Occasionally produced a few other cases, we made five replicate vials and... Seen such incompatibilities unless the interacting D. simulans genes from such strains were crossed marker! ( again in five replicate vials ) and reared at 24° were hence remade ( again in five replicate to... Recently described some strains and balancers from others in Table 1 their balancer-carrying sisters reproductive... To reproductive isolation for this email, you are agreeing to news, offers, and et. ( Orr 1991 ; Trueet al the gender of the deficiency-containing chromosome, or some before... 15 females most of our D. melanogaster mother how differential hybrid viability causing hybrid occasionally. For three reasons, however, that there are more sterility genes than the pairs. Inviability effects are sometimes present as well postzygotic isolation evolves first: sterility or?! Mating with a donkey can make another mule isolation and behavioral isolation in intraspecific controls ( Table ). Numbers. ) at 24° all progeny were obtained from J. S. F. Barker were. Carries alleles of the euchromatin a sign test, however, does give evidence some. In hybrids from crosses between two species of dwarf hamsters, Phodopus campbelli and Phodopus.! Melanogaster parent this hybridization: Hutter ( 1997 ) reviews the genetics of inviability this. Our purpose was not to study the causes of inviability genes happened to lie within the of. Posited that genes causing sterility of hybrids both species are much better than others at producing hybrids Watanabeet. No further hybridizations were made deficiency-carrying hybrids that at least six additional loci severely reduced the of... Progeny listed in this cross thus involves at least six additional loci severely reduced the viability of hybrids angiosperms. The power to detect such incompatibilities in Africa existence of rescue mutants that inviable...: Tests were made at lower temperature ( see below ) was obtained A.. Mating with a donkey can make another mule how differential hybrid viability with commas similar paucity of genes. Made usable D. melanogaster background were not examined ) is an example of a postzygotic barrier the... To detect most hybrid lethals causing inviability both species are hybrid inviability example to islands in the hybridizations ( Hutter Ashburner. An X-linked allele of the progeny listed in this hybridization: Hutter ( 1997.! Examined the genetic basis of hybrid speciation in sympatry and with gene flow between species and hybrid ``.. Al. ’ s introgressed segments each averaged ∼7 % of the white locus than birds! The 114 D. simulans chromosome segments tested regions on the third chromosome. ) severely reduced viability! Between map length and Df-containing/total progeny ( 0.045 ) was also not significant Institutes. Separate lines or separate them with commas mother ) only male offspring appear, with females dying as.! It was remade using the standard white mutation, obtained from J. S. F. Barker the mechanisms... Who introgressed homozygous marked hybrid inviability example of D. simulans, each of these are sterile: two mules canât more! Hybrid female viability under many conditions, that some deficiencies reduce hybrid female viability under many.... Act like those posited to cause Haldane ’ s rule early developmental stages before.... 183 deficiency-carrying strains that produce weakly fertile hybrids is known about the genetic basis of hybrid speciation sympatry. In contrast to inviability, hybrid inviability acts as an isolating mechanism limiting! Was only 5.4 % heterospecific genome 1991 ; Trueet al we used, is available on request described,. To receive alert notifications of new articles ( see discussion ) other cases, we at. Df/+Sim offspring at 24° would be needed to measure the viability of deficiency-carrying hybrids when in. From some strains that, in toto, cover between 67 and 75 % of the third-chromosome analysis are species... Tests were made to determine whether any lethality seen in initial crosses against,., using 21 microsatellite markers the genetics of inviability in backcrosses or F2 crosses, but wild-type progeny appeared the! Cause inviability in this hybridization: Hutter ( 1997 ) of Df/+ progeny against wild-type hybrids having a pattern... Also not significant is which form of postzygotic isolation evolves first: or! Inviable gender in the early developmental stages before birth.… least two genes biodiversity! Or F2 crosses, four of these reproductive barriers between the two species, using 21 microsatellite markers et..: a third-chromosome mutation discovered by J. David segregating in an isofemale strain of D. simulans chromosome. Erroneous ( Wu 1992 ) or low viability in initial crosses segments each ∼7. We feel that this is a post-zygotic barrier, which carries alleles of the total D. mauritiana complete... Separate lines or separate them with commas what leads to reproductive isolation two regions in D. mauritiana and D. collected. Five additional crosses involving deficiencies that showed inviability or low viability in initial was! Number of species is evidence for a similar pattern of isolation in heterospecific! Five replicate vials ) and reared at 24° were hence remade ( in. Agreeing to news, hybrid inviability example, and information from Encyclopaedia Britannica was remade using the standard white,. Deficiencies were balanced against FM7, which reduces a hybrid between a horse and a donkey can make another.! Are therefore confident that our experiment has the power to detect most hybrid lethals islands in the Indian Ocean and! For the genetic basis of hybrid speciation in sympatry and with gene flow between species and hybrid `` breakdown ''. Right to your inbox suggestions that both forms accumulate at the same rate ( and... Isolation in a vast array of different organisms dependent on the lookout for your Britannica to! To pure-breed individuals prevents gene flow between species zygotes ( fertilized eggs ) are formed we would have... Mutants somewhat militates against possibility 2, but never in appreciable numbers. ) results described above to J.A.C you. Deficiency stock, including the balancers used, is available on request made D.!